Journal of Microwave Power and Electromagnetic Energy (JMPEE)

 

TITLE

Comments on Frey’s  “Data Analysis Reveals Significant Microwave-Induced Eye Damage in Humans” [PDF]

AUTHORS

E.L.Wike and E.J. Martin

1985

20

3

181-184

YEAR

VOLUME

ISSUE

PAGES

 

Abstract

Frey's critique and analysis of the Appleton-McCrossan and Appleton et al studies were examined. Frey is criticized for: (1) ignoring pooling problems in his chi-square test; (2) not analyzing the opacity data in Appleton et al; (3) not analyzing the data on vacuoles and posterior subcapsular iridescence in Appleton and McCrossan and Appleton et al; and (4) failing to do log-linear analysis which is appropriate for the design in the two studies. Application of log-linear tests to the opacity data in both studies leads to the conclusion that subject age was significantly associated with the occurrence of opacities, but, contrary to Frey's conclusion, microwave radiation was not.